ArtCraft is not an Adobe product. This independent comparison is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Adobe Inc. or the ArtCraft team.

ArtCraft vs Adobe: Full Comparison (2026)

TL;DR: ArtCraft is a free, open-source (MIT or Apache-2.0) AI image and video studio that makes you compose scenes in 2D and 3D before generating. Adobe Firefly is a paid cloud service with a free daily tier and plans from $9.99 a month (Adobe). ArtCraft's Photoshop- and After Effects-style apps, PhotoCraft and EffectCraft, are free but still alpha, so Adobe stays the safer choice for professional editing today (PhotoCraft, EffectCraft).

Last updated: 26 October 2026 · Adobe prices are US list prices shown on adobe.com that day, excluding tax and limited-time discounts.

ArtCraft vs Adobe: comparison table

Price: ArtCraft plans vs Adobe plans

ArtCraft's pricing page says the app "can be used without paying for a subscription" if you bring your own compute and third-party subscriptions. The plans buy generation credits and state "You own ArtCraft forever" (pricing). Adobe sells subscriptions, and Firefly's credits are shared across the Firefly web app, mobile app and compatible desktop apps (Firefly plans).

Sources: getartcraft.com/pricing, Adobe Firefly plans, Adobe Photoshop plans. On 26 October 2026 ArtCraft showed 20% off yearly plans and Adobe showed limited-time discounts on some tiers; the table shows regular prices. A credit buys a different amount of output on each service, so compare by the models you plan to use.

AI image and video generation: ArtCraft vs Firefly

ArtCraft focuses on control before generation. You place actors in a consistent location, pose characters, turn images into 3D meshes and composite layers in 3D, then render with your chosen model (README). Its catalog spans 16 image, 25 video, 5 audio, 11 3D-mesh and 5 world models, from families such as FLUX, Seedream, Kling, Veo, Hunyuan 3D and Marble.

Firefly's plans cover image, video and audio generation, with premium features such as Text to Video and Generate Speech paid for in generative credits, and access to "leading AI models from Adobe, Google, and more". Its free tier includes popular models such as Nano Banana (Firefly plans). Both tools give you access to third-party models. ArtCraft's difference is the 3D scene-building step and the open code.

Image editing: PhotoCraft vs Photoshop

PhotoCraft is the ArtCraft team's image editor, described as "an open-source, clean-room reimplementation of Adobe Photoshop" that keeps menus and shortcuts "where your hands expect them" (README). It opens and saves layered PSD and PSB files and supports 8-, 16- and 32-bit documents in RGB, CMYK, Lab and Grayscale (PhotoCraft page). Its developers are blunt about its status: early alpha, "not yet a Photoshop replacement for daily professional work", with gaps in generative features, typography depth and plug-in compatibility.

Photoshop 27.x needs Windows 10 or 11, or macOS 14, 15 or 26, 8 GB of RAM (16 GB recommended) and 10 GB of disk space, plus an internet connection for activation (Adobe requirements). Its official guide covers features such as Generative Fill, Generative Expand, Neural Filters and the Plugin Marketplace.

Motion graphics: EffectCraft vs After Effects

EffectCraft is a compositor built around compositions and layers, with Lottie import and export built in. Its README is candid: the first commit was on 1 October 2026, it "isn't yet a replacement for After Effects on client work", it cannot open .aep/.aepx projects, and After Effects plug-ins don't run (README). After Effects costs $22.99 a month on an annual plan, with a 7-day free trial (Adobe).

Where Adobe is the better choice

• Professional, deadline-driven editing: both PhotoCraft and EffectCraft say they are not ready for it yet.
• Existing After Effects projects and plug-ins: EffectCraft can't open .aep files or run AE plug-ins (source).
• Generative editing inside a full photo editor: PhotoCraft lists AI/generative features as its biggest gap (source); Photoshop has Generative Fill and Expand (source).
• Mobile apps: Firefly and Photoshop offer web and mobile versions (source).

Where ArtCraft is the better choice

• You want open-source code you can audit, fork or self-build (MIT/Apache-2.0).
• You want to stage scenes in 3D, pose characters and keep locations consistent before generating (features).
• You want to avoid a subscription by bringing your own compute (pricing).
• You work on Linux and are happy to use the Crafting Apps' Linux packages or build ArtCraft from source (apps, build guide).

Switching from Adobe: migration notes

• Photoshop files: PhotoCraft opens and saves PSD/PSB, but it is early alpha, so test your own files first (README).
• After Effects projects: they don't transfer. EffectCraft uses its own .ecproj format; Lottie is the shared exchange format (README).
• Plug-ins: Adobe plug-ins are not supported in PhotoCraft or EffectCraft (PhotoCraft, EffectCraft).
• Workflow: the Crafting Apps copy familiar layouts and shortcuts; ArtCraft adds an account sign-in at first launch (apps, quick start).

Ready to try it? Use our safe ArtCraft download guide, or go back to the ArtCraft and Crafting Apps overview, the ArtCraft product deep dive, or PhotoCraft details.

Also compare: FilmCraft vs CapCut

Related reading

• FigCraft vs Figma
• FilmCraft vs CapCut
• FilmCraft download
• ArtCraft Launcher
• ArtCraft MCP